A Nightmare on Elm Street - Haley Edition
Pedestrian. That's about all I can muster. Which is a shame, because individual ideas are interesting and haven't been explored in Freddy lore. But they're not explored here either. Samuel Bayer has a keen eye and Rooney Mara is well above average for this sort of material, but there are fundamental flaws that keep it from rising anywhere above (or sometimes even at) 'meh'. Chief among them being Freddy simply isn't scary as shown here. The filmmakers up the backstory but fail at the first hurdle with, frankly, ugly (and not in a good way) makeup for Freddy in monster mode. The occasional nice kill can't earn back what should have been the easiest win for the film - the icon.
Pedestrian. That's about all I can muster. Which is a shame, because individual ideas are interesting and haven't been explored in Freddy lore. But they're not explored here either. Samuel Bayer has a keen eye and Rooney Mara is well above average for this sort of material, but there are fundamental flaws that keep it from rising anywhere above (or sometimes even at) 'meh'. Chief among them being Freddy simply isn't scary as shown here. The filmmakers up the backstory but fail at the first hurdle with, frankly, ugly (and not in a good way) makeup for Freddy in monster mode. The occasional nice kill can't earn back what should have been the easiest win for the film - the icon.
Comment