Battlestar Galactica [spoilers obviously]

[Nathan]

The character or the actor?

[Abraham Smashington]

The character.

[Abraham Smashington]

But I did not feel bad for Callie. FUCK YOU.

[Martin]

But I did not feel bad for Callie. FUCK YOU.

Especially since when we never saw her naked...

He was running away from Gaeta singing.

Well they HAD to justify the airlock...

"The mutiny, Mr.Gaeta, the ship could have lived with. But your singing..."

WHOOOOOOOOOOOSH

[Captain Russ]

Season 2 did. Easily. Like Octo Dad (Who is dat?) said, the one year later reveal was a gutpunch. Add to the the BSG Atmospheric Drop (coolest sequence in the history of TV btw) and it's clear for me that it was the high point. Problem was that the expected drop afterward nearly made me stop watching, beside the Baltar trial. The whole Starfuck vision thing was retarded. I hoped she died painting that shit on the wall.

And I miss Fat Apollo, whom the wife called Fatollo.

The drop was noticeable considering the heights they shot for, but the mystery of the final five and the chance to see Baltar get away with everything was enough to keep me loyal (with this series I am, to a fault).

The fun of it now is watching everyone going about their bidness while THEY ARE IN THE COMPANY OF ROBUTTS. Strangely, it makes the rewatchapalooza even better.

[Martin]

The drop was noticeable considering the heights they shot for, but the mystery of the final five and the chance to see Baltar get away with everything was enough to keep me loyal (with this series I am, to a fault).

The fun of it now is watching everyone going about their bidness while THEY ARE IN THE COMPANY OF ROBUTTS. Strangely, it makes the rewatchapalooza even better.

Oh it was also enough to keep me loyal, but in retrospect it was pretty boring when Baltar was away. I hated how Baltar is a very very minor character when he's a prophet in S4, yet they had to show Tigh disturbingly banging Six.

[Captain Russ]

Almost to the end of S3, so we'll see how large the gulf is the second time around. I hope it has lessened with time.

I agree that Baltar was unfairly reduced in prominence.

[Howard]

I find the re-watch to be much better than I expected (currently in Season One). Knowing the ending, the character interaction is definitely more poignant. Also Gaeta? The character we found out later is gay? Has a bathroom stall scene with Gaius. lol

[Howard]

The Saul/Ellen reunion in Season One is especially poignant. You know, I have to think they did know who the Final Five were.....

[Howard]

I forgot how much I love Lucy Lawless. Damn. She's good.

[gravedigger]

Netflix finally took the pilot off "disc only" status so I think I'm going to give this show a shot. Should I just assume that I'll hate the finale like apparently everyone else does?

[Howard]

I love the finale. You will love the finale. Anyone that doesn't love the finale can get fracked.

[B_Metal]

Fracked - lameness personified. If you wanna say fucked say fucked and bleep it like Southland. That very word makes me despise anything BSG related and I KNOW that's ridiculous but I won't budge. I'm not saying the show is bad as I have never watched but shoe horning a made up curse word like they do is just fucking lame.

**Edit, I'm aware not having seen the show means I'm open to criticism about having no knowledge of it, but C'MON SOOOOOOOOOOOOON, FRACKED?

[Captain Russ]

Netflix finally took the pilot off "disc only" status so I think I'm going to give this show a shot. Should I just assume that I'll hate the finale like apparently everyone else does?

Huh? I loved it. Give it a go, man. It's a fun ride.

[Captain Russ]

Fracked - lameness personified. If you wanna say fucked say fucked and bleep it like Southland. That very word makes me despise anything BSG related and I KNOW that's ridiculous but I won't budge. I'm not saying the show is bad as I have never watched but shoe horning a made up curse word like they do is just fucking lame.

**Edit, I'm aware not having seen the show means I'm open to criticism about having no knowledge of it, but C'MON SOOOOOOOOOOOOON, FRACKED?

This has to be the silliest thing you have ever written. Watch it. Out of context I sort of understand your point, but to begrudge some great sci-fi, nay, just plain great storytelling for it? Well, that is just tragic.

Also, Ed Lover is homeless? Who saw that coming?